Acta Universitatis Carolinae Iuridica (AUCI) is the main journal of the Faculty of Law of Charles University. It has been published since 1954 and is one of the traditional law journals with a theoretical focus.
As a general law journal, it publishes longer studies and shorter articles on any relevant issues in legal theory and international, European and national law. AUCI also publishes material relating to current legislative issues. AUCI is a peer-reviewed journal and accepts submissions from both Czech and international authors. Contributions by foreign authors are published in their original language – Slovak, English, German, French.
AUCI is a theoretical journal for questions of state and law. It is published by Charles University in Prague, Faculty of Law, through Karolinum Press. It is published four times a year, the dates of publication can be found here.
Articles published in AUCI undergo an independent peer review process, which is anonymous on both sides. Reviewers from the field give their opinion on the scientific quality of the paper and the suitability of publication in the journal. In the case of comments, the opinion is sent back to the author with the possibility of revising the text (see Guidelines for Authors – Per Review Process for more details).
The AUCI journal (ISSN 0323-0619) is registered in the Czech National Bibliography (kept by the National Library of the Czech Republic) and in the Index to Foreign Legal Periodicals (kept by the American Association of Law Libraries). AUCI has been assigned a periodical registration number MK E 18585.
In 2021 the journal AUCI was the first journal of the Faculty of Law of Charles University to be included in the prestigious international database Scopus. This Elsevier database is the largest abstract and citation database of peer-reviewed literature in the world. The editors of the journal expect from the inclusion in the elite Scopus database not only an increase in the readership of the journal, but also an increase in interest in the publication of papers by both Czech and foreign authors.
AUCI is an open journal and all its content is published both on the faculty website and on the Karolinum Press website. Access to it is free of charge. The homepage of AUCI is on the Karolinum Press website.
The AUCI journal uses the Creative Commons license: CC BY 4.0.
Long-term archiving of the digital content of the journal is provided by Portico.
AUC IURIDICA, Vol 71 No 1 (2025), 159–177
The First Step towards a More Inclusive Environment in Sports? Case Note of the ECtHR’s Semenya v. Switzerland Judgment
Gergely Ferenc Lendvai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.14712/23366478.2025.9
published online: 03. 03. 2025
abstract
The case of Caster Semenya, a South African athlete, has been a subject of interest for more than a decade. The intersex athlete, who identifies as a woman, is not only one of the world’s most successful middle-distance runners, but also one of the most controversial sports rights issues. The IAAF (now known as World Athletics) has repeatedly sought to restrict Semenya under various regulations, claiming that she enjoys an unfair competitive advantage because of her high testosterone levels. The presentation of the case before the ECtHR is intended to elaborate on the above polemical situation. In this paper, we will attempt to review the Court’s position in detail, including the judicial proceedings that preceded the ECtHR’s decision. Reactions and reflections of civil organisations to the decision’s direction will also be underlined to provide a more holistic overview of the case. The study aims to contribute to the literature on LGBTQIA+ rights and to the discourse on the rights of marginalised communities.
keywords: Caster Semenya; discrimination; intersexuality; LGBTQ rights; sports law
references (22)
1. AMY-CHINN, D. Doing Epistemic (in) Justice to Semenya. International Journal of Media & Cultural Politics. 2011, Vol. 6, No. 3, pp. 311-326. CrossRef
2. BALOYI, J. Commission for Gender Equality welcomes the European Court of Human Rights' ruling on Caster Semenya. In: South African Government [online]. 12. 7. 2023 [cit. 2024-08-29]. Available at: https://www.gov.za/speeches/commission-gender-equality-welcomes-european-court-human-rights%E2%80%99-ruling-caster-semenya-12.
3. BATELAAN, K. - ABDEL-SHEHID, G. On the Eurocentric Nature of Sex Testing: The Case of Caster Semenya. Social Identities. 2020, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp. 146-165. CrossRef
4. BIANCHI, A. Transgender Women in Sport. Journal of the Philosophy of Sport. 2017, Vol. 44, No. 2, pp. 229-242. CrossRef
5. CAMPORESI, S. - MAUGERI, P. Caster Semenya: Sport, Categories and the Creative Role of Ethics. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2010, Vol. 36, No. 6, pp. 379-379. CrossRef
6. COOPER, J. Protecting Human Rights in Sport: Is the Court of Arbitration for Sport up to the Task? A Review of the Decision in Semenya v IAAF. The International Sports Law Journal. 2023, Vol. 23, pp. 151-175. CrossRef
7. Controversy surrounding Olympic boxing champion Imane Khelif: what does the future of gender inclusion in elite sport look like? In: Erasmus University Rotterdam [online]. 14. 8. 2024. [cit. 2024-11-08]. Available at: https://www.eur.nl/en/news/controversy-surrounding-olympic-boxing-champion-imane-khelif-what-does-future-gender-inclusion-elite.
8. Court says Semenya can appeal testosterone limit for female athletes. In: Reuters [online]. 12. 7. 2023. [cit. 2024-08-29]. Available at: https://www.reuters.com/sports/athletics/semenya-wins-appeal-over-human-rights-violations-2023-07-11/.
9. DASGUPTA, L. Russian twister and the World Anti-Doping Code: time to shun the elitist paradigm of anti-doping regime. International Sports Law Journal. 2017, Vol. 17, No. 1-2, pp. 4-8. CrossRef
10. FARHAM, B. Caster Semenya - the Questionable Practice of Gender Verification. South African Medical Journal. 2019, Vol. 109, p. 543. CrossRef
11. FRANKLIN, S. What Statistical Data of Observational Performance Can Tell Us and What They Cannot: The Case of Dutee Chand v. AFI & IAAF. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2018, Vol. 52, No. 7, pp. 420-421. CrossRef
12. HEGGIE, V. Testing Sex and Gender in Sports; Reinventing, Reimagining and Reconstructing Histories. Endeavour. 2010, Vol. 34, No. 4, pp. 157-163. CrossRef
13. IMRAY, G. Olympic champion Semenya says she is 'elated' after ruling in testosterone case but has suffered. In: AP [online]. 12. 7. 2023 [cit. 2024-08-29]. Available at: https://apnews.com/article/semenya-human-rights-court-ruling-testosterone-fe11e239e68c943781f024c99162747c.
14. KARKAZIS, K. et al. Out of Bounds? A Critique of the New Policies on Hyperandrogenism in Elite Female Athletes. The American Journal of Bioethics. 2012, Vol. 12, No. 7, pp. 3-16. CrossRef
15. KIHL, L. A. - SCHULL, V. Understanding the Meaning of Representation in a Deliberative Democratic Governance System. Journal of Sport Management. 2020, Vol. 34, No. 2, pp. 173-184. CrossRef
16. LOLAND, S. Caster Semenya, Athlete Classification, and Fair Equality of Opportunity in Sport. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2020, Vol. 46, pp. 584-590. CrossRef
17. MAGUBANE, Z. E. Spectacles and scholarship: Caster Semenya, Intersex Studies, and the Problem of Race in Feminist Theory. Signs. 2014, Vol. 39, No. 3, pp. 761-785. CrossRef
18. NYONG'O, T. The Unforgivable Transgression of Being Caster Semenya. Women & Performance: A Journal of Feminist Theory. 2010, Vol. 20, No. 1, pp. 59-100. CrossRef
19. PASTOR, A. Unwarranted and Invasive Scrutiny: Caster Semenya, Sex-Gender Testing and the Production of Woman In 'Women's' Track and Field. Feminist Review. 2019, Vol. 122, No. 1, pp. 1-155. CrossRef
20. SVÁK, J. Intersex Sportswomen as a Driving Force of Transnational Human Rights Protection. Právny obzor. 2023, Vol. 106, No. 6, pp. 543-566. CrossRef
21. SWARR, A. L. et al. South African Intersex Activism: Caster Semenya's Impact and Import. Feminist Studies. 2019, Vol. 35, No. 3, pp. 657-662.
22. United Nations. UN experts welcome European Court ruling upholding rights of women athletes in Semenya v. Switzerland. In: UNHRC [online]. 17. 7. 2023 [cit. 2024-08-29]. Available at: https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2023/07/un-experts-welcome-european-court-ruling-upholding-rights-women-athletes.
The First Step towards a More Inclusive Environment in Sports? Case Note of the ECtHR’s Semenya v. Switzerland Judgment is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
230 x 157 mm
periodicity: 4 x per year
print price: 65 czk
ISSN: 0323-0619
E-ISSN: 2336-6478
