Willis’s Circle? Exploring the Conflict Between Galenic and Harveian Physicians Through Treatises on Respiration

Thomas Willis was one of the most influential physicians of seventeenth-century England, yet his career has received less scholarly scrutiny than many of his contemporaries. Willis promoted the belief system of William Harvey, contrasting the Galenic traditions of the previous millennia. I argue that Willis and his circle’s work on respiration and respiratory illnesses showcase the competitive and aggressive environment of mid-seventeenth-century English medical research.

1. BOYLE Robert, New Pneumatical Experiments about Respiration, Philosophical Transactions 5, 1670, pp. 2035-2056 CrossRef

2. BOYLE Robert, Medicinal experiments: or, A collection of choice and safe remedies for the most part simple and easily prepared, useful in families, and very serviceable to country people, London 1693

3. CARON Louis, Thomas Willis: the Restoration and the First Works of Neurology, Medical History 59/4, 2015, pp. 525-553 CrossRef

4. CASHIN Conlan, Willisius Male Vindicatus Sive Medicus Oxoniensis Mendacitatis et Inscitiaa Detectus, Dublin 1671

5. CHAMBERLAYNE Edward, The Second Part of the Present State of England Together with Divers Reflections upon the Antient State Thereof, London 1671

6. CLARK Andrew, 'Brief Lives,' chiefly of Contemporaries, set down by John Aubrey, between the Years 1669 & 1696, II, Oxford 1898

7. CLERICUZIO Antonio, From van Helmont to Boyle. A study of the transmission of Helmontian chemical and medical theories in seventeenth-century England, The British Journal for the History of Science 26/3, 1993, pp. 303-334 CrossRef

8. COMPSTON Alastair, 'All manner of ingenuity and industry': A bio-bibliography of Dr Thomas Willis 1621-1675, Oxford 2021 CrossRef

9. GRELL Ole Peter (ed.), Paracelsus: The Man and his reputation, his Ideas and their Transformation, Leiden 1998 CrossRef

10. DEWHURST Kenneth (ed.), Richard Lower's Vindicatio: A defence of the experimental method, Oxford 1983

11. FRANK JR. Robert, Harvey and the Oxford Physiologists, Berkley 1980

12. HARVEY William, Exercitatio Anatomica de Motu Cordis et Sanguinis in Animalibus, trans. by Robert Willis, New York 1847

13. HAWKINS Michael, Piss Profits: Thomas Willis, His Diatribae Duae and the Formation of His Professional Identity, History of Science 49/1, 2011, pp. 1-24 CrossRef

14. HUGHES J. Trevor, Thomas Willis 1621-1675: His Life and Work, London 1991

15. ISLER Hansruedi, Thomas Willis 1621-1675: Doctor and Scientist, New York 1968

16. JOHNS Adrian, The Nature of the Book: Print and Knowledge in the Making, Chicago 2000

17. LOWER Richard, Treatise on the Heart as well as on the Motion and Color of Blood and on the Transit of Chyle through it, London 1669

18. LOWER Richard, Dr. Lowers, and several other eminent physicians, receipts containing the best and safest method for curing most diseases in humane bodies: very useful for all sorts of people, especially those who live remore [sic] from physicians, London 1700

19. WEST John, Marcello Malpighi and the discovery of the pulmonary capillaries and alveoli, American Journal of Physiology-Lung Cellular Molecular Physiology 304/6, 2013, pp. L383-L390 CrossRef

20. MARTENSEN Robert L, The Brain Takes Shape: An Early History, Oxford 2004 CrossRef

21. MEYNELL Geoffrey Guy, Materials for a Biography of Dr Thomas Sydenham, Folkestone 1988

22. MILLER WS, Thomas Willis and his De Phthisis Pulmonari, American Review of Tuberculosis 5, 1922, pp. 934-949

23. OLDENBURG Henry, An Account of Mr. Richard Lower's newly published Vindication of Doctor Willis's Diatriba de Febribus, Philosophical Transactions 1, 1665, pp. 77-78 CrossRef

24. PIERCE Robert, Bath Memoirs: Or, Observations in Three and Forty Years Practice, at the Bath, Bristol 1697

25. STEFANAKIS Georgios - NYKTARI Vasileia - PAPAIOANNOU Alexandra - ASKITOPOULOU Helen, Hippocratic concepts of acute and urgent respiratory diseases still relevant to contemporary medical thinking and practice: a scoping review, BMC Pulmonary Medicine 20/165, 2020, pp. 1-7 CrossRef

26. SYDENHAM Thomas, The compleat [sic] method of curing almost all diseases to which is added an exact description of their several symptoms, trans. by Randal Taylor, London 1694

27. SYMONDS Charles, Thomas Willis, F.R.S. (1621-1675), Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London 15, 1960, pp. 91-97 CrossRef

28. WALMSLEY Jonathan, John Locke on Respiration, Medical History 51/4, 2007, pp. 453-476 CrossRef

29. WILLIS Thomas, A medical-philosophical discourse of fermentation, or, Of the intestine motion of particles in every body [sic], trans. by Samuel Pordage, London 1681

30. WILLIS Thomas, An essay of the pathology of the brain and nervous stock in which convulsive diseases are treated of, trans. by Samuel Pordage, London 1681

31. WILLIS Thomas, Pharmaceutice rationalis: or, An exercitation of the operations of medicines in humane bodies. Shewing the signs, causes, and cures of most distempers incident thereunto: In two parts: As also a treatise of the scurvy and the several sorts thereof, with their symptoms, causes, and cure, London 1678

32. WILLIS Thomas, The Anatomy of the Brain and the Description and Use of the Nerves in the Remaining Medical Works of that Famous and Renowned Physician Dr Thomas Willis, trans. by Samuel Pordage, London 1681

33. WILLIS Thomas, Thomas Willis's Oxford Lectures, trans. by Kenneth Dewhurst, Oxford 1980

34. WOOD Anthony, Athenae Oxonienses: An exact history of all the writers and bishops who have had their education in the University of Oxford. To which are added the fasti, or annals of the said University, ed. by Philip Bliss, II, London 1813