Exploring the potential of historical images for the investigation of glacier changes: the case of Belvedere Glacier, Italian Alps

Historical images dispersed in various archives can be instrumental in documenting processes connected to glacier changes in mountains. A series of more than 29 engravings and photographs of the Monte Rosa east face have been found covering the period since 1789. Some images were produced by a combination of photography and engraving, a common approach before practical techniques for printing halftone images were introduced. Using a repeat photography approach, the present study documents the changes in the extent and debris cover of the Belvedere Glacier. Based on visual comparison of images, it appears that the debris cover of the lower part of the glacier developed mainly during the period of the 1860s–1880s. Furthermore, the image series documents the evolution of the terminus both in terms of elevation and shape, as well as a breach in lateral moraine which could be dated back to the end of the 19th century, well before the reported glacier lake outburst flood in 1904.

1. Bollati, I., Smiraglia, C., Pelfini, M. (2013): Assessment and selection of geomorphosites and trails in the Miage Glacier Area (Western Italian Alps). Environmental Management 51, 951-967. CrossRef

2. von Brevern, J. (2009): Counting on the unexpected: Aimé Civiale's mountain photography. Science in Context 22(3), 409-437. CrossRef

3. Bridson, G. D. (1989): From xylography to holography: five centuries of natural history illustration. Archives of Natural History 16(2), 121-141. CrossRef

4. Brunner, K., Welsch, W. (2002): High-mountain cartography of the German and the Austrian Alpine Clubs. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 57(1-2), 126-133. CrossRef

5. Byers, A. C. (1987): An assessment of landscape change in the Khumbu region of Nepal using repeat photography. Mountain Research and Development 7(1), 77-81. CrossRef

6. Byers, A. C. (2007): An assessment of contemporary glacier fluctuations in Nepal's Khumbu Himal using repeat photography. Himalayan Journal of Science 4(6), 21-26. CrossRef

7. Byers, A. C. (2017): A qualitative assessment of contemporary glacier loss in the Cordillera Blanca, Peru, using repeat photography. Revista de Glaciares y Ecosistemas de Montaña 2, 10-10.

8. Cerney, D. L. (2010): The use of repeat photography in contemporary geomorphic studies: an evolving approach to understanding landscape change. Geography Compass 4(9), 1339-1357. CrossRef

9. Chand, P., Sharma, M. C., Bhambri, R., Sangewar, C. V., Juyal, N. (2017): Reconstructing the pattern of the Bara Shigri Glacier fluctuation since the end of the Little Ice Age, Chandra valley, north-western Himalaya. Progress in Physical Geography 41(5), 643-675. CrossRef

10. Chen, H., Yin, K., Wang, H., Zhong, S., Wu, N., Shi, F., Zhu, D. Zhu, Q., Wang, W., Ma, Z., Fang, X., Li, W., Zhao, P., Peng, C. (2011): Detecting one-hundred-year environmental changes in western China using seven-year repeat photography. PLOS ONE 6(9): e25008. CrossRef

11. Civiale, A. (1882): Les Alpes: au point de vue de la géographie physique et de la géologie: voyages photographiques dans le Dauphiné, la Savoie, le Nord de l'Italie, la Suisse et le Tyrol (Vol. 1). J. Rothschild.

12. Davis, T. (1989): Photography and landscape studies. Landscape Journal 8(1), 1-12. CrossRef

13. Diolaiuti, G., D'Agata, C., and Smiraglia, C. (2003): Belvedere Glacier, Monte Rosa, Italian Alps: Tongue Thickness and Volume Variations in the Second Half of the 20th Century. Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research 35(2), 255-263. CrossRef

14. Finsterwalder, S. (1897): Der Vernagtferner - Seine Geschichte und seine Vermessung in den Jahren 1888 und 1889. Wissenschaftliche Ergänzungshefte des Deutschen und Österreichischen Alpenvereins 1(1), 1-95.

15. Fischer, L., Huggel, C., Kääb, A., and Haeberli, W. (2013): Slope failures and erosion rates on a glacierized high-mountain face under climatic changes. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms 38(8), 836-846. CrossRef

16. Frangne, P. H. (2010): The Dehiscent Image. Théophile Gautier and the Mountain Photographs of the Brothers Bisson. Études photographiques 25, 210-242, https://journals.openedition.org/etudesphotographiques/3062.

17. Gibbs, P. (1910): The Wonders of the World. Hutchinson & Co. London.

18. Gnifetti, G. (1858): Nozioni topografiche del Monte Rosa ed ascensioni su di esso. Crotti.

19. Garimoldi, G. (2005): Immagini di montagna e immagini d'alpinismo. Memoria e ricerca: rivista di storia contemporanea. Fascicolo 19, 1000-1021.

20. Haeberli, W., Kääb, A., Paul, F., Chiarle, M., Mortara, G., Mazza, A., Deline, P., Richardson, S. (2002): A surge-type movement at Ghiacciaio del Belvedere and a developing slope instability in the east face of Monte Rosa, Macugnaga, Italian Alps. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift 56(2), 104-111. CrossRef

21. Hattersley-Smith, G. (1966): The symposium on glacier mapping. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 3(6), 737-741. CrossRef

22. Hopkinson, M. (2017): Book Review: The Print before Photography. An Introduction to European Printmaking 1550-1820 by Anthony Griffiths. The British Art Journal 17(3), 92-94.

23. Jacobson, K. (2015): John Ruskin's Lost Daguerreotypes. Daguerreotype Journal 2(3), 8-19.

24. Kääb, A., Huggel, C., Haeberli, W., Cordola, M., Barbero, S., Mortara, G., Semino, P., Tamburini, A., Viazzo, G. (2004): Glacier hazards at Belvedere Glacier and the Monte Rosa east face, Italian Alps: processes and mitigation, Internationales Symposion Interpraevent 2004 - Riva/Trient.

25. Kull, C. A. (2005): Historical landscape repeat photography as a tool for land use change research. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift-Norwegian Journal of Geography 59(4), 253-268. CrossRef

26. Kropáček, J. (2019): Erosion dynamics in the southern Tibetan Plateau at a century time scale from historical photographs. Journal of Arid Environments 161, 47-54. CrossRef

27. Kropáček, J., Vařilová, Z., Nyssen, J. (2019): Historical aerial and terrestrial photographs for the investigation of mass movement dynamics in the Ethiopian Highlands. Land Degradation & Development 30(5), 483-493. CrossRef

28. Levin, J. A. E. (1980): The golden age of illustration: popular art in American magazines, 1850-1925. University of Pennsylvania.

29. Mazza, A. (2000): Some results of recent investigations on Ghiacciaio del Belvedere (Anzasca valley, western Alps) taking into account the glacier mechanics. Geografia Fisica e Dinamica Quaternaria 23(7), 59-71, https://www.jstor.org/stable/1552378.

30. Milner, C. D. (1946): Focal Press, London

31. Monterin, U. (1922): Il Ghiacciaio di Macugnaga dal 1870 al 1922. Bollettino del Comitato Glaciologico Italiano 5, 12-40.

32. Monterin, U. (1926): La fine della fase progressiva e l'inizio della nuova fase di ritiro dei ghiacciai italiani nel Monte Rosa 1922-1925. Zeitschrift für Gletscherkunde 15(1), 31-54.

33. Mortara, G. and Tamburini, A. (2009): Il ghiacciaio del Belvedere e l'emergenza del Lago Effimero, Regione Piemonte. Societa Meteorologica Subalpina.

34. Mustalish, R. A. (1997): The development of photomechanical printing processes in the late 19th century. Topics in photographic preservation 7, 73-87.

35. Nüsser, M. (2000): Change and persistence: contemporary landscape transformation in the Nanga Parbat region, northern Pakistan. Mountain Research and Development 20(4), 348-355. CrossRef

36. Nüsser, M. (2001): Understanding cultural landscape transformation: A re-photographic survey in Chitral, eastern Hindukush, Pakistan. Landscape and Urban Planning 57(3-4), 241-255. CrossRef

37. Nüsser, M., Baghel, R. (2014): The emergence of the cryoscape: Contested narratives of Himalayan glacier dynamics and climate change. In: Schuler B. (ed.): Environmental and climate change in South and Southeast Asia: How are local cultures coping? Leiden, Boston: Brill (Climate and Culture 2), 138-156. CrossRef

38. Nüsser, M., Schmidt, S. (2021a): Assessing glacier changes in the Nanga Parbat region using a multitemporal photographic dataset. Data in Brief 37: 107178. CrossRef

39. Nüsser, M., Schmidt, S. (2021b): Glacier changes on the Nanga Parbat 1856-2020: A multi-source retrospective analysis. Science of The Total Environment 785: 147321. CrossRef

40. Nyssen, J., Haile, M., Naudts, J., Munro, N., Poesen, J., Moeyersons, J., Frankl, A., Deckers, J., Pankhurst, R. (2009): Desertification? Northern Ethiopia re-photographed after 140 years. Science of The Total Environment 407(8), 2749-2755. CrossRef

41. Osterman, M. (2013): The technical evolution of photography in the 19th century. The Concise Focal Encyclopedia of Photography, 5-16. CrossRef

42. Paranunzio, R., Laio, F., Chiarle, M., Nigrelli, G., Guzzetti, F. (2016): Climate anomalies associated with the occurrence of rockfalls at high-elevation in the Italian Alps. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences 16(9), 2085-2106. CrossRef

43. Porro F., Somigliana, C. (1919): Ghiacciaio do Macugnaga. Bollettino del Comitato Glaciologico Italiano 3, 187-189.

44. Reclus, E. (1876-1894): The universal geography: earth and its habitants. Southern Europe (Greece, Turkey in Europe, Rumania, Servia, Italy, Spain and Portugal), Vol. 2., London: J. S. Virtue & Co.

45. de Saussure, H. B., Zanzi, L., Martinoni, R., Rainaldi, G., Martinoni, R. (1989): Viaggi intorno al Monte Rosa. Fondazione Arch. Enrico Monti.

46. de Saussure, H. B. (1779-1796): Voyages dans les Alpes, Neuchâtel, Vol. 4.

47. Savale, C. (1994): Les campagnes photographiques de Martens en Suisse et en Savoie. Histoire de l'art 25(1), 67-77. CrossRef

48. Schlagintweit H. and Schlagintweit A. (1850): Untersuchungen über die physicalische Geographie der Alpen in ihren Beziehungen zu den Phaenomenen der Gletscher, zur Geologie, Meteorologie und Pflanzengeographie. Leipzig.

49. Schlagintweit A. and Schlagintweit H. (1854): Neue Untersuchungen über die physicalische Geographie und die Geologie der Alpen. Leipzig.

50. Schmidt, S., Nüsser, M. (2009): Fluctuations of Raikot Glacier during the last 70 Years: A case study from the Nanga Parbat Massif, northern Pakistan. Journal of Glaciology 55(194), 949-959. CrossRef

51. Schulze, S. (2021): Seen from above: Wilhelm Halffter's photographs of 1854, depicting the terrain models of Hermann and Adolph Schlagintweit. In Hybrid Photography, Routledge, 41-56. CrossRef

52. Sealy, P. (2016): After a photograph, before photography (takes command). The Journal of Architecture 21(6), 911-937. CrossRef

53. Smiraglia, C., Diolaiuti G., eds. (2015): The New Italian Glacier Inventory. EvK2CNR, Bergamo, https://sites.unimi.it/glaciol/index.php/it/catasto-dei-ghiacciai-italiani/.

54. Stefaniak, A. M., Robson, B. A., Cook, S. J., Clutterbuck, B., Midgley, N. G., Labadz, J. C. (2021): Mass balance and surface evolution of the debris-covered Miage Glacier, 1990-2018. Geomorphology 373: 107474. CrossRef

55. Steiner, D., Zumbühl, H. J., and Bauder, A. (2008): A scientific view based on pictorial sources. In: Orlove B, Wiegandt E and Luckman B, eds. Darkening peaks: glacier retreat, science, and society, Berkeley: University of California Press, 83-99. CrossRef

56. Tamburini, A., Mortara, G. (2005): The case of the Effimero lake at Monte Rosa (Italian Western Alps). Studies, field surveys, monitoring. Proc. 10th ERB Conference Progress in surface and subsurface water studies at plot and small basin scale (Turin, 13-17 October 2004), Torino, http://www.cnr.it/prodotto/i/88695.

57. Tamburini, A., Villa, F., Fischer, L., Hungr, O., Chiarle, M., Mortara, G. (2013): Slope instabilities in high-mountain rock walls. Recent events on the Monte Rosa east face (Macugnaga, NW Italy). In: Margottini, C., Canuti, P., Sassa, K. (eds) Landslide Science and Practice. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. CrossRef

58. Trimble, S. W. (2008): The use of historical data and artifacts in geomorphology. Progress in Physical Geography 32(1), 3-29. CrossRef

59. Truffer, M., Kääb, A., Harrison, W. D., Osipova, G. B., Nosenko, G. A., Espzua, L., Gilbert, A., Fischer, L., Huggel, C., Craw Burns, P. A. and Lai, A. W. (2021): Glacier surges. In: Haeberli, W. and Whiteman, C. (eds.). Snow and Ice-Related Hazards, Risks, and Disasters. Elsevier, 417-466. CrossRef

60. Vukovic, M., Fischer, A. (2022): The Camera as a Tool in Geography: Parallels between Friedrich Simony's Pictures of the Dachstein and the Use of Photographic Images in Geography Today. Umění/Art 70(3). CrossRef

61. Viatimages (2024): Available online: https://www2.unil.ch/viatimages/index.php?lang=fr&projet=viaticalpes&#/ouvrage-221 (accessed on 4.6.2024).

62. von Welden, F. L. F. and Welden, L. (1824): Der Monte-Rosa: eine topographische und naturhistorische Skizze, nebst einem Anhange der von Herrn Zumstein gemachten Reisen zur Ersteigung seiner Gipfel. C. Gerold.

63. WGMS (World Glacier Monitoring Service, 2024): Fluctuations of Glaciers Browser. Available online: https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/836c66d14c8b410f940355056ddb1bf8?org=uzh (accessed on 14.02.2024).

64. Zängl, W., Hamberger, S. (2004): Gletscher im Treibhaus. Tecklenborg, Steinfurt.

65. Zumbühl, H. J., Nussbaumer, S. U. (2018): Little Ice Age glacier history of the Central and Western Alps from pictorial documents. Cuadernos de Investigación Geográfica 44(1), 115-136. CrossRef

66. Zumbühl, H. J., Steiner, D. and Nussbaumer, S. U. (2008): 19th century glacier representations and fluctuations in the central and western European Alps: An interdisciplinary approach. Global and Planetary Change 60(1-2), 42-57. CrossRef

67. Zumstein, J. (2020): Cinque viaggi alle vette del Monte Rosa (1819-1822) editor Crivellaro, P., Zeisciu, Alagna Valsesia.